Image
Enlarge Image
Eugene and Clare Thaw Collection of American Indian Art
Drawing - Comanche Killing Deer

Previous Next Exhibit Page Home Search
Record 389/826
Copyright New York State Historical Association, Cooperstown, NY
Object ID T0388
Object Name Drawing - Comanche Killing Deer
Description "Comanche Killing Deer" Drawing; Medium/Materials: Pencil and crayon on paper; Marks: At bottom in pencil: "Deer" "Comanche";
Dimensions H-9 W-14 inches
Early Date 1875
Late Date 1878
Medium Pencil and crayon on paper
Place of Origin USA
People Kiowa (possibly)/
Provenance (1) H. Malcolm Grimmer. Santa Fe, New Mexico.; (2) Eugene V. Thaw 1 January 1993.;
History Scholarly Attributions: [1] Joyce Szabo identified the artist as Wohaw (or Wo-Haw) and the location of Fort Marion. GVT - 12 August 1996. [2] Letter from Janet Berlo - 4 August 1996 discussing the gallery labels: "Ledger drawings. As I mentioned to you last week in regard to the two labeled "Wo-Haw 1875-78:" absolutely not. I know Wo-Haw's work better than any other ledger artist. Most of it is in St. Louis. For his Fort Marion style, see Moira Harris, BETWEEN TWO CULTURES: KIOWA ART FROM FORT MARION (Pogo Press, 1989) which illustrates all his known works. // Is there some reason it is labeled Wo-Haw or is it someone's attribution? If there is firm documentary evidence linking it to Wo-Haw (who died in 1924) it would have to be late. We know of no post-fort Marion works by him. And no matter who did these drawings, they were not done at Fort Marion. They are in the style of works done in Kiowa territory by Silverhorn and others in the 1880s and 90s. In particular, that 3-dimensional deer form is not seen in Kiowa drawings until thelate 1880s, in the work of Silverhorn."
Used Kiowa (possibly)
For access to this image, contact the Registrar, Fenimore Art Museum, (607) 547-1444.

   
Last modified on: March 02, 2006