Image
Enlarge Image
Eugene and Clare Thaw Collection of American Indian Art
Knife

Previous Next Exhibit Page Home Search
Record 34/826
Copyright New York State Historical Association, Cooperstown, NY
Object ID T0033a-b
Object Name Knife
Description Iroquois Knife; Medium/Materials: Wood, leather, steel; Marks: On bottom of knife, rectangular sticker in black ballpoint ink: "F901" and in black ink: "W10433";
Dimensions W-2 L-9 inches
Early Date 1850 ca.
Place of Origin New York, USA
People Iroquois/
Provenance (1) Jonathan and Philip Holstein. Cazenovia, New York.; (2) Eugene V. Thaw 6 October 1989.;
History Scholarly Attributions: The second paragraph of Ted Brasser's catalogue entry reads: "The popularity of human faces carved on the handles of these work knives throughout the Northeast makes reference to the long-standing tradition of carving human effigies on other items. However, as many of the early colonists came from countries where the carving of human and animal figurines on the handles of knives and spoons was quite common, European influence may have been a possible factor in this art form." Cath Oberholtzer commented - 9 July 1996 - ".. my own feelings towards European influence are two-fold: 1) that even if there is documentation (not provided in this instance), that one should also acknowledge that the Iroquois had earlier traditions of human figurines in other contexts; and (2) on the same line of reasoning, there are examples / studies of intentional adoption of European forms to subsume native meaning with "acceptable" form (eg. Micmac adoption of syllabics and Cree use of floral imagery).
Used Iroquois
For access to this image, contact the Registrar, Fenimore Art Museum, (607) 547-1444.

   
Last modified on: March 02, 2006